Login error with compiled Smack's

Smack Smack Dev
1

Hi all,

I am having trouble to have a modified Spark running over a modified Smack.

I haven’t been able to perform together:

 1) checkout a full revision  from Smack SVN --> ok

 2) checkout a full revision  from Spark SVN  --> ok

 3) compile Smack with ant -->  ok

 4) get the 4 generated jar  files: __smack*.jar__, and put it into  <spark-project-root>/build/lib/dist

 5) compile Spark with ant --> ok

 6) then authenticate properly --> problems  always

Account errors or server errors are discarded.

I have a modified Spark, with a released Smack working ok with a released Openfire.

But modified Smack and modified Spark don’t run together for me.

My compiled Smack also makes to crash a released Spark, if I just replace jar files.

What I pretend is to have Proxy support in my modified Spark.

For sure in next Smack release, 3.0.5, this feature will be included,

but it is more than a year from last release, 3.0.4.

Smack revisions I chose to test:

  - Smack revision 10407 (19 may  2008): Updated Jingle implementation

  - Smack revision 10429 (22 may  2008): Fixed SASL authentication that required a realm like  DIGEST-MD5.

  - Smack revision 10674 (14  july 2008): Added proxy support à the feature I was  pretending to have in my Spark.

My tests:

 - Spark revision 10595 (26 june  2008) + Smack revision 10407 (downloaded from Spark SVN) --> ok: compile, run and  connect

 - Spark revision 10595 (26 june 2008) + Smack revision 10407  (built by me from SRC) --> compile, run, but  crashes: SASLAuthentication failed

 - Spark revision 10595 (26 june  2008) + Smack revision 10429 (built by me from SRC) --> compile, run, but  crashes: SASLAuthentication failed

  • Spark revision 10595 (26 june 2008) + Smack revision 10674 (built by me from SRC) --> compile, run, but crashes: SASLAuthentication failed

    • Spark revision 10832 (17 may 2008) + Smack revision 10407 (downloaded from Spark SVN) --> compile, run, but crashes: SASLAuthentication failed

    • Spark revision 10832 (17 may 2008) + Smack revision 10407 (built by me from SRC) --> compile, run, but crashes: SASLAuthentication failed

    • Spark revision 10832 (17 may 2008) + Smack revision 10429 (built by me from SRC) --> compile, run, but crashes: SASLAuthentication failed

    • Spark revision 10832 (17 may 2008) + Smack revision 10674 (built by me from SRC) --> compile, run, but crashes: SASLAuthentication failed

My error, every time:

14-oct-2008 13:12:06 org.jivesoftware.spark.util.log.Log warning

ADVERTENCIA: Exception in Login:

SASL authentication failed:

    at  org.jivesoftware.smack.SASLAuthentication.authenticate(SASLAuthentication.java: 327)

    at  org.jivesoftware.smack.XMPPConnection.login(XMPPConnection.java:438)

    at  org.jivesoftware.LoginDialog$LoginPanel.login(LoginDialog.java:860)

    at  org.jivesoftware.LoginDialog$LoginPanel.access$400(LoginDialog.java:200)

    at  org.jivesoftware.LoginDialog$LoginPanel$1.construct(LoginDialog.java:606)

    at  org.jivesoftware.spark.util.SwingWorker$2.run(SwingWorker.java:131)

    at  java.lang.Thread.run(Unknown Source)

I feel confused about this. I have searched into forums, and read Smack and Spark documentation, but nothing found.

Any help would be very appreciate.

Thanks in advance.

Diego

2

Hi Diego,

if you didnt notice before, your problem was my problem,

and my “partial” solution was explained here,

**to update Smack and to have Proxy Support **in Spark:

regards

pellex